Recommended
Mr. Pepperoni
at Prince Street Pizza · Nolita
What it is
Straight pepperoni on the same focaccia-like base — for the purists.
Why it’s worth ordering here
The Spicy Spring — a Sicilian square with curled, crispy pepperoni and spicy vodka sauce.
The Morano family's Nolita shop is famous for its thick-crusted Soho Squares. The Spicy Spring is the slice that built the reputation — thick pepperoni cups holding little pools of spicy oil on a focaccia-like base.
Heather tip
Saturday morning opening is the hack — go right at 10:00 AM to skip the midday line.
Links & references
27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012