Sunday · #1
NY Pizza Suprema
NY Pizza Suprema
Across from Penn Station since 1964 — the Sunday goodbye.
Midtown / Penn Station 10:30 AM – 12:00 AM
What to order
The classic cheese slice or the Upside-Down Sicilian.
Menu Highlights
Heather tip
Two minutes from Moynihan Hall — you can literally eat and board.
Why it’s on the list
Same Italian family since opening in 1964, right across from Penn Station and MSG. The Slice Harvester gave it a perfect score. A fitting last slice before the Amtrak home.
History
—
Opened 1964 by the Riggio family; still family-operated three generations later.
—
Directly across 8th Ave from Madison Square Garden and Penn Station — it's fed the Moynihan Hall era and every era before it.
Did You Know?
The 'Upside-Down' Sicilian is a Suprema original — the cheese goes under the sauce so the top stays crisp under a broiler pass.
Notable Reviews
Slice Harvester (Colin Hagendorf)
“A perfect slice. I can't explain it better than that.”
Address: 413 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001